The Crime Fiction Lover Awards 2021: The Winners

6 Mins read
Crime Fiction Lover Awards 2021

Finally, the votes have been counted and verified and we can announce the winners of the inaugural Crime Fiction Lover Awards…

But before we do that, we want to congratulate all the crime authors out there who have released stories in the last year, those who were nominated by readers, and those who made it onto the shortlists for our awards. You bring joy and satisfaction to crime fiction lovers everywhere. Whether you have won an award or not, you deserve our thanks.

Now we move on to the main event… Who’s won? Scroll down and see. The winners have been chosen by our readers through two rounds of online polling. In each category, our team has also selected an Editor’s Choice from the shortlists.

If you haven’t read these books and authors, or watched our top crime shows, these 12 awards provide the very best recommendations.

You can grab the winning books on our page at

Crime Fiction Lover Awards 2021 best crime novel badge

Best Novel Winner: The Night Hawks by Elly Griffiths

The Night Hawks by Elly Griffiths front cover

Crime Fiction Lover readers chose The Night Hawks by UK author Elly Griffiths for the Best Novel Award and it’s easy to see why. The 13th Dr Ruth Galloway book is blessed with gripping mystery, a bleak and beautiful setting, and a story with tendrils reaching into Britain’s ancient past alongside a contemporary investigation. It’s a book that will envelop you, demanding that you read the rest of the series… if you haven’t already. Congratulations to Elly Griffiths and her publishers.
Read The Night Hawks

Best Novel Editor’s Choice: Razorblade Tears by SA Cosby

Razorblade Tears by SA Cosby front cover

SA Cosby is rightly being hailed as one of the most important new voices in crime fiction and with Razorblade Tears he proves just how relevant the crime novel can be for society. As well as a gripping tale of revenge, this is an urgent and insightful commentary on modern America. At times violent and deeply poignant, this tale is nonetheless poetic and heartfelt. Cosby writes with such empathy that readers sympathise with his deeply flawed characters, which leads to an understanding of their plight. Congratulations to SA Cosby and his publishers.
Read Razorblade Tears

Crime Fiction Lover Awards 2021 Best debut novel badge

Best Debut Winner: The Source by Sarah Sultoon

The Source by Sarah Sultoon front cover

Our Best Debut category, which was keenly contested in the reader vote, was won by Sarah Sultoon and her novel, The Source. It’s a book in which a TV news journalist goes undercover to tackle the tough topic of human trafficking. A former journalist herself, Sarah Sultoon handles it deftly even where it ventures into the horrors of child abuse and sexual exploitation. More than that, the story is sublimely told, which is why The Source is so highly rated by our readers. Congratulations to Sarah Sultoon and Orenda Books.
Read The Source

Best Debut Editor’s Choice: Winter Counts by David Heska Wanbli Weiden

Winter Counts by David Heska Wanbli Weiden front cover

We value originality and we love discovering writers who take us to worlds we’ve yet to discover. The world in Winter Counts by David Heska Wanbli Weiden is the Rosebud Reservation in South Dakota, home to the Lakota Nation. Virgil Wounded Horse is the hardboiled badass on the rez who is tasked with dealing with an opioid ring. Forget the drugs, though, because this author’s writing is an addictive of blend of genre and literary fiction. Published last year in the US and this year in the UK, Winter Counts is a gem of a book. Congratulations to David Heska Wanbli Weiden and his publishers.
Read Winter Counts

Crime Fiction Lover Awards 2021 Best in Translation

Best in Translation Winner: The Girl Who Died by Ragnar Jonasson, translated by Victoria Cribb

The Girl Who Died by Ragnar Jonasson front cover

If you like Nordic noir with the temperature turned all the way down, and the dark, lonely atmosphere dialled up to 11, then Ragnar Jonasson’s The Girl Who Died is the book you have to read. This is the tale of a teacher who moves to an outpost community in northern Iceland at right about the same time that another outsider visits the town and vanishes. Is it Una’s isolation and alcoholism that haunts her, is it a ghost, or is it the tale of this missing stranger? Our readers love how the author combines horror and crime in this gripping standalone. Congratulations to Ragnar Jonasson, Victoria Cribb and their publishers.
Read The Girl Who Died

Best in Translation Editor’s Choice: Riccardino by Andrea Camilleri, translated by Stephen Sartarelli

Riccardino by Andrea Camilleri front cover

Just think how much enjoyment Italy’s best-known crime author has given his readers over the decades, not to mention those who have devoured the Montalbano series on the telly. Our Editor’s Choice award in this category goes to the final novel in a wonderfully entertaining series and there is a touch of metafiction as Camilleri and Salvo Montalbano go toe to toe over who’s really in charge of the story. With its slightly absurd and wickedly funny tones, plus its richly endearing characters, Riccardino brings a close to the series and a tear to the eye. Posthumous congratulations to Andrea Camilleri, translator Stephen Sartarelli and their publishers.
Read Riccardino

Crime Fiction Lover Awards 2021 Best Indie novel badge

Best Indie Novel Winner: The Strangers of Braamfontein by Onyeka Nwelue

The Strangers from Braamfontein by Onyeka Nwelue front cover

There was a varied shortlist in our Best Indie Novel category, as you might expect. In the end, our readers chose The Strangers of Braamfontein, a hard-hitting novel set in South Africa, written by Nigerian author Onyeka Nwelue. There’s a bit of everything in this Johannesburg thriller – a dead prostitute, violent gangs, corruption and racism as the young Nigerian immigrant Osas tries to navigate an environment where there are few people he can trust. The characters are authentic, even down to the dialect – a poignant tale of migration and ghetto living. Congratulations to Onyeka Nwelue and his publishers.
Read The Strangers of Braamfontein

Best Indie Novel Editor’s Choice: The Quiet People by Paul Cleave

The Quiet People by Paul Cleave front cover

Our Editor’s Choice award in the indie category goes to another novel set in the Southern Hemisphere – The Quiet People by Paul Cleave. Man, this guy can weave a plot and he has produced one of the twistiest novels we’ve seen in ages. Crime fiction lovers and authors alike will relate – this is a book about a husband and wife writing team who have boasted that they can plan the perfect murder. When their son goes missing… naturally they become suspects. This is a tragic take that says much about our rush to judgement in the age of social media. Congratulations to Paul Cleave and his publishers at Orenda Books.
Read The Quiet People

Crime Fiction Lover Awards 2021 Best crime show badge

Best Crime Show Winner: Line of Duty

Line of Duty season six crime show

When series six of Line of Duty aired in the UK, its average audience was over 15 million people for each episode. More Brits watch Line of Duty than watch the news, so it’s no surprise that this most gripping of crime dramas – which frequently has us shouting at our screens – led the way with our readers. It’s rare to say that a TV show sets the agenda for crime fiction – it’s usually novels that influence the small screen – but today we often get press releases comparing books to Line of Duty. Police interviews have never been so tense, and creator Jed Mercurio piles one storyline on top of another with aplomb. Intriguing, irresistible, simply superb. Congratulations to Jed Mercurio, the cast and the producers at the BBC and World Productions.

Best Crime Show Editor’s Choice: Mare of Easttown

Mare of Easttown crime show

Both a mystery and a powerful community tragedy, Mare of Easttown has just about everything crime fiction lovers want, and then some. Kate Winslet turns in a career-defining performance as Mare Sheehan, a police detective in a rundown Pennsylvania town who is the glue holding her family together, and possibly the whole town too. She’s trying to solve the murder of a single mother as well as the case of a young woman who went missing over a year ago. Created by Brad Inglesby and directed by Craig Zobel, Mare of Easttown has a superbly layered story with a perfectly authentic setting and characters. Perfect television. Congratulations to Brad Inglesby, Craig Zobel, the cast and the producers at HBO.

Crime Fiction Lover Awards 2021 Best author badge

Best Author Winner: Elly Griffiths

Crime author Elly Griffiths

Double congratulations go to Elly Griffiths, who has not only won the Best Novel award but has also been chosen as Best Author by our readers. Intelligent and atmospheric, her novels are quintessentially British delivering expertly rendered settings, intrigue, touches of humour and a sense of history. With three series on the go – Dr Ruth Galloway (13 books), The Brighton Mysteries (six books) and Harbinder Kaur (two books) – she gives readers a choice between contemporary mysteries that often reach into the past, Brighton in the 1960s and nuanced cases solved by a gay detective, respectively. Every novel she writes is hugely anticipated by us and by our readers. It makes us ask: why aren’t Elly’s stories on the telly? Congratulations to Elly Griffiths, our Best Author of 2021.
Read The Crossing Places

Best Author Editor’s Choice: Ian Rankin

Scottish crime author Ian Rankin

Here at Crime Fiction Lover there is always competition to be the reviewer whenever a new Rebus novel comes along. This year, however, instead of a new instalment in the life of John Rebus in Edinburgh, Ian Rankin gave himself a new challenge. At the request of William McIlvanney’s family, he was charged with completing a novel featuring Jack Laidlaw, the Glasgow detective at the heart of Tartan noir’s defining trilogy. Working from McIlvanney’s documents, Rankin created The Dark Remains, a Laidlaw prequel that for us and for legions of crime fiction lovers is a true highlight of 2021. Congratulations, Ian Rankin.
Read The Dark Remains

Next year…

We hope to run the Crime Fiction Lover Awards in 2022, and perhaps make it bigger and better. We are looking for sponsors, so if you’re a brand or organisation that would like to get involved in supporting crime fiction please have a look at our Promote page and get in touch.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related posts

The Last Word by Elly Griffiths

Elly Griffiths is best known for her Ruth Galloway series, which came to a halt in the North Norfolk salt marshes last year. Griffiths has set that series aside for the time being at least, but the good news for the fans of this hugely…

Interview: Elly Griffiths

Congratulations to Elly Griffiths. When it’s released on 30 January 2024, The Last Word will be her 30th crime novel. The date is fitting and hopefully, despite the title, this won’t be her last book. As readers, we keep coming back for Griffiths’ vivid characters…

The Crime Fiction Lover Awards 2023: The Winners

A drum roll please. Or maybe some moody midnight saxophone would be more fitting, given our genre. Whatever the tune, whatever the syncopation, the moment has come to unveil the winners of the 2023 Crime Fiction Lover Awards. Go ahead and scroll down to feast…
Crime Fiction Lover