Smoke and Ashes

3 Mins read

Written by Abir Mukherjee — There has been a burning fire of anticipation for the third adventure of Captain Sam Wyndham in colonial Calcutta where the flames of the freedom movement are fanning out from Gandhi’s non-cooperation campaign for Indian independence from the imperial yoke. After all, the London-based Glaswegian author of Indian extraction has already seen his first two novels – A Rising Man and A Necessary Evil – populating the shortlists and in several cases bagging top awards.

Wyndham is an ex-Scotland Yard detective and a veteran of World War I, scarred by survivor guilt and the loss of his wife to the influenza that killed so many. It’s 1921 and he’s been in India for two years now. Like Sherlock Holmes before him, he enjoys recreational drugs and has become dangerously dependent on opium. His nights are wiped out under the influence and his days are spent struggling to function through his cravings.

However, it is a visit to an opium den that puts Wyndham on his next crime case when he discovers a dying man with his eyes gouged out and a knife in his chest. Stumbling from the scene, Wyndham disposes of any evidence that he was there, as his presence in the den must be kept secret from his superiors.

The next day he and his ultra bright Indian sergeant Surrender-Not Bannerjee (Surendranath) are sent to investigate the murder of an Indian Christian military nurse who is found with similar ritualistic injuries on the riverbank. Wyndham can’t tell anyone about the same modus operandi, as he fears his adversaries in the brutal military intelligence Section H have his cards marked already. Before long he discovers a sinister link between the murders at the heart of the British rule.

To make matters worse on the personal front, his love-interest, Annie Grant, who previously helped him begin to overcome the grief of losing his wife, has taken up with a flash American multi-millionaire tea trader. His life is a mess.

There are more than the murders for Wyndham and Surrender-Not to deal with. The freedom movement is gathering pace in Calcutta. A friend of the sergeant’s family, Chitta-Ranjan Das, a real life independence leader, has joined Gandhi as his chief lieutenant in Bengal and is planning a mass non-violent demonstration and rally. And, this is all days before the arrival of the Prince of Wales, the future Edward VIII, which is guaranteed to fuel the unrest further. The British are terrified that the publicity surrounding any trouble during the prince’s visit will be seen around the world.

Wyndham is ordered to deliver an ultimatum to Das on behalf of the Viceroy to cancel the protest or have his volunteer organisations outlawed. What actually happens is that Das and Wyndham discuss the matter with cordial good-humour as fellow gentlemen. Das is committed to provoking a reaction and Wyndham wants a quiet life. The policeman has a lot more time for Das than the military thugs and bent cops he encounters in the Imperial Police Force and the native units. All Wyndham can do is hope there is no mass bloodshed at the hands of the British military. He understands that the actual threat is from the downtrodden millions who could rise up instead of praying.

Questions have often been asked about whether Wyndham is a little too enlightened towards the plight of the native population for an educated British man of his time. There are a few occasions when he refers to Indians as the great unshod and unwashed etc but any racist thoughts he keeps to himself. Recently Mukherjee addressed this at Newcastle Noir, saying Wyndham is a man out of his time so as to avoid the traits we don’t want to see in a protagonist.

What makes these books rise above many others to acclaim is how Mukherjee tells the compelling story of this neglected and fascinating period of Anglo-British history in a cracking rollercoaster style with wit and credibility.

For crime fiction with a completely different tone, try Vaseem Khan’s Baby Ganesh books, or something by Brian Stoddart. Read our 2015 interview with Abir Mukherjee here.

Harvill Secker

CFL Rating: 5 Stars

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related posts

The Rabbit Factor by Antti Tuomainen

Translated by David Hackston — The Man Who Died, Palm Beach Finland, Little Siberia… Antti Tuomainen’s books have quirky titles and the slightly surreal sense of humour that they suggest continues inside each of them. Now we have The Rabbit Factor, with its lurid orange…

Paris Police 1900 – the dark and dangerous French crime drama

For anyone who loves historical crime fiction, Paris Police 1900 is a sensory treat with an intriguing and often terrifying story at its heart. Airing through October 2021 on Saturday evenings on BBC Four, it’s packed with period accuracy, political finagling, brutal violence, mystery and…

The Man Who Died Twice by Richard Osman

The man is a TV gameshow phenomenon in the UK, but questions were raised when Richard Osman announced he was writing a crime novel. Could this incomer cut the mustard? Book sales of more than a million copies since The Thursday Murder Club was published in…
Crime Fiction Lover