All Day and a Night by Alafair Burke

2 Mins read

The title All Day and a Night refers to prison slang for a sentence of life without parole – precisely the sentence given to Anthony Amaro almost 21 years ago for the murder of six women. Five murders were in upstate New York, in the small town of Utica, with Amaro only moving to the city itself for his final slaying. He was caught by the NYPD just when the state legislature had voted to return to the death penalty. Both sides cut a bargain preventing his execution. He pleaded guilty to the final murder accepting life without parole, and the District Attorney won a quick conviction avoiding a costly trial

Amaro’s victims were all prostitutes and all had limbs broken postmortem, a detail never leaked to the press. In the present day, New York’s incumbent DA, up for re-election soon, now has reason to question Amaro’s guilt. He has received an anonymous letter questioning the verdict, and a female psychotherapist has just been murdered at her practice with her body disfigured in the same way. Conscious of his elected position and public concerns about law enforcement corruption, and badgered by Linda Moreland, a celebrity lawyer Amaro has hired to represent him, the DA appoints a new team to review the evidence. It will be headed up by ambitious Assistant DA Max Donovan and two NYPD detectives of his choice. Donovan decides to pick the best available – Ellie Hatcher and JJ Rogan – which immediately causes problems since he and Hatcher are in a relationship.

Meanwhile, Moreland catches the team off-balance in court. She is able to cast doubt on the retired detective who took Amaro’s confession and has DNA evidence to suggest somebody else murdered the New York victim. The judge gives the team just three days to convince her Amaro should stay in prison, and in practice that will mean finding the killer of the most recent victim. When they fail, Amaro is sprung and everybody converges on Utica. Amaro is sequestered in an out of the way motel, with Moreland aware that one tactic the cops can try is to charge him with one of the original murders he was never tried for. Hatcher and Rogan are sent down to help locate him, and at the same time check up on how the Utica police handled the case all those years ago. Moreland has hired a promising young lawyer, Carrie Black, to assist her. Carrie is in fact the half-sister of one of the victims, and has been seduced by the idea of finding out what really happened.

My gosh, this is a difficult book to follow. Burke is a professor of criminal law and writes with authority about the legal proceedings, and is especially good with the interaction between the police and the DA’s office. However she also writes with a lawyer’s concern for detail, which gets in the way of the story. There are also just too many twists and the result what could be a 200 page book that actually goes to 350. To her credit, Burke is trying to provide more than the typical mystery here, and at the book’s heart are the relationships between Max Donovan and Ellie Hatcher, and between Carrie and her past. She may have thought she’d escaped her small town past but she hasn’t. Unfortunately most of this becomes little more than soap opera, and about two thirds of the way through the book I found my patience becoming stretched. In truth if I weren’t reviewing this book I doubt I would have finished it, but with a firmer editorial hand this could have been an enjoyable procedural.

Faber and Faber

CFL Ratings: 2 Stars

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related posts

The Death Watcher by Chris Carter

The world of crime fiction is a broad church, featuring everything from snooping grannies in sleepy rural hamlets to blood spattered serial killers, and everything in between. At the darkest end of that spectrum comes Chris Carter, whose Robert Hunter series is definitely not for…

Missing White Woman by Kellye Garrett

Some book titles are enigmatic, leaving you puzzling until a clue as to their meaning perhaps appears at an unexpected moment; others make no sense at all, even after you’ve turned the final page. Then there are those that lay it out, pure and simple…

A classic revisited: The Silence of the Lambs

Has there ever been a more recognisable, more evil villain than Dr Hannibal Lecter? Not many of us will be able to shake the image of Anthony Hopkins’s eyes behind that facial restraint, nor the sound of his terrifying, slithering slurp. I’m also guessing that…
Crime Fiction Lover